Tuesday, 6 February 2018

Bad experiences with Trinity Marina - Mooring and brokerage

I write to warn all boaters about Trinity Marina in Hinckley, and also their boat brokerage business.
I used to moor my boat at this marina.
Before I was allowed to start mooring there November 2014 I was asked for a £500 deposit, which was duly paid. As soon as I put the boat on brokerage I started to ask for the return of the deposit. Initially they seemed to ignore this request, but after a string of emails from me they responded saying they could find no record that I had actually paid the deposit, despite every annual invoice stating that it had been paid. 
I do not know if this was simply disorganisation, or incompetence, or something worse on their part. However, I am a meticulous man and was able to supply proof that it had been paid, after which they did refund the charge; but beware - make sure you retain proof of payment, or it seems quite possible that you will not get this charge refunded.

Now we get to the sad story of the brokerage. For many reasons I decided to sell up, and thought the easy option would be to use the marina's own brokerage business.

I signed their standard brokerage contract, and handed over all the keys, leaving the boat in their care, clean and fully locked up. After a negative survey which included various comments which were factually incorrect I decided to take the boat to a different area and a different firm in the hope that this incompetent surveyor would not be chosen again. 
When I arrived to take some photos of the boat I discovered the following:
1) every single lock and padlock on the boat was unlocked
2) a pair of walkie-talkies was missing
3) the local edition of the Nicholson canal guide was missing
4) there was a 'pop-stud' fastener torn out of the front cratch cover
5) there was excrement in the toilet pan - the person had not even bothered to open the hatch in the pan to deposit it into the holding tank
6) the switches for both the bilge pumps had been moved from their 'automatic' position to 'off'.
Frankly, considering the locks were all open it was little short of a miracle that no further items were missing!

I raised this with the marina, & they told me to write to the manager. I did so, and again appeared to be ignored until a sufficient number of emails had arrived in their inbox, when I was told that I should have put personal items out of sight. 
I then pointed out that the missing items were A) not personal items but part of the boat's equipment and B) were out of sight; and that this comment did not even begin to deal with the other issues. They are now trying to hide behind a clause in the contract saying I accepted responsibility for ensuring the security and cleanliness of the boat, and are refusing any compensation.
Since they did not tell me when the viewings were going to happen (how could they - they didn't know when a punter might turn up and ask to view) or indeed when they had happened - which they could have done, I had no way of knowing when I was supposed to come and check. 
They also knew that I lived in Coventry (half an hour from the marina) and worked in Great Rissington (over an hour away) and could not therefore be popping round randomly to check, on the off chance that I would coincide with a viewing or her return from a survey. 

This clause therefore makes it an 'unfair contract' in that there is no way it can be complied with by any boat owner unless they are living on the boat, or close enough to it to see when a viewing is taking place.

I had entrusted the boat to their care, and she was clean and secured when I did so.

The depredations and damage were a result of culpable negligence in their reasonable duty of care.

They have refused mediation, are still refusing any settlement, and have told me to only contact them through my lawyer, in the hope no doubt that I will not be prepared to incur a lawyer's charges, and will quietly drop the issue....

I strongly recommend any boat owner who might be thinking of using this brokerage service to think again, and if you already are doing so, you might be wise to cancel the contract and go elsewhere - or at least check up on the boat's condition as frequently as you possibly can!

The content of this post was sent to Trinity Marina, giving them the chance to come to terms with me before publication. They have refused to do so.

Tuesday, 1 December 2015

Are we to bomb ISIS in Syria?

There are so many reasons not to do so - every refugee being another one - and so few for it.
As Christians, we are called to search for ways to end violence, not to increase it. It would be a desperately black irony to increase the bombing at the same time as we are building up for the Birth of Christ, the Prince of Peace!
Has anybody asked the Syrians whether they want this intervention? Some recent "vox pop's" on TV seem to suggest (and it can be put no more strongly than that) that they are not in favour. They believe the real problem is Assad, and once he is deposed then they will be in a position to get rid of ISIS... 
We do not have a very good track record in our interventions in the Middle East - ever since (at least) 1918 all western interventions in the region have resulted in greater problems a few years down the line, and there is no reason to suppose this one will be any different.
We also have a very poor record for looking after our service personnel when they return from combat (with the possible exception of their physical health) - whether or not they remain in the forces. If we are to commit the military to combat we need to have far better care for them when they return - if only for the sake of our civilian population, who will have to cope with trained killers with PTSD!
No was is won by air power alone but by ground forces. There seem to be very varied ideas about whether or not there are sufficient ground forces which we are happy to support. Also, look at what happened when we last supported local ground forces in the region - they turned into the Taliban! Can we be sure this will not happen again? 
Removal of ISIS without some process already in place to fill the power vacuum is likely to result in a far worse situation than is currently the case, and in any case can not be done without this being the will of the local population. You only have to look at Afghanistan for confirmation of this. We have NO right to decide who is to govern them.
We also have to bear in mind the strife we will be causing to the non-ISIS civilian population in the region. There are already huge streams of refugees from the country. Adding our bombs to the mix will only make this worse. Every single person who is forced to flee their home is another reason why we should not do this. 
The weapons system we would be using may be smaller with fewer civilians killed than those of other countries, but there still will be such casualties, and I do not believe that adding our planes to the mix will result in a decrease in missions flown by other nations, nor that not adding ours would mean an increase from them. There would also be a greatly increased risk of 'friendly fire' incidents.
If, as Mr Cameron asserts, we are already in the top group of targets for terrorist attacks from them (or people inspired by they) is this not a direct consequence of the fact that we are as deeply involved as we already are? We are bombing them in other countries, and gathering a lot of the intelligence on them within Syria. Does anyone suppose this has gone un-noticed by them?
Yes, they do need to be tackled, but not militarily. It would be far better to do so through diplomacy - and please don't try to tell me that we 'never negotiate with terrorists'. This is exactly what we did to end the Troubles in NI, and is the only way to persuade them to lay down their arms voluntarily. Their (partial) military defeat is likely to inspire more recruits to their cause, whether there or as terrorists around the world. Like a Hydra, if you cut off one head nine more are likely to grow.

Tuesday, 16 June 2015

Weird clock faults


OK - what is the weirdest fault you have come across?
I have on my bench at the moment something which at first hearing sounds pretty strange... It is a twin fusee bracket clock with (unusually) 1/2-hr rack strike. The only fault was the single blow due at 1.30 which consistently came at 1.36 instead...
When I checked it out the explanation was far simpler than  expected. The 1/2-hr strike is limited to one blow by the rack hook not being lifted far enough to clear the second & subsequent teeth on the rack, but only the short first one. At 1.30 - uniquely for the 1/2-hr strikes - the rack tail also falls into contact with the snail. It turns out that it was hitting the snail on a marginally high spot so the gathering pallet tail was just not clearing the pin on the rack. By 1.36 the snail was back to the correct height and the train was free!
A quick tickle with a file and the problem was solved... and yes, I could also have solved it by moving the hour wheel round one tooth on the motion-work pinion since the hour hand is on a cylindrical collet, but if the snail has been badly formed in the first place I see no argument for not correcting it.

Monday, 15 June 2015

AGM of the BHI

Before the AGM, on reading the June HJ I had severe misgivings about the election of members to the Board of Directors. It sounded as though the three candidates who had withdrawn had been persuaded to, and I feared this might have been against their true wishes, due to undue pressure being put on them to do so.
This is because,sadly, not enough information was made public in advance.
The facts that were not known - at least to me! - are as follows...
The Hall is in a severe state of dilapidation, and is also contaminated with asbestos fibres, though to re-assure members, these are not an issue so long as they stay undisturbed in certain cellars and crawl-spaces. Since it is a Grade 2* Listed building we are legally obliged to maintain it - we can't just lock it up and go elsewhere, unless we can release ourselves from the responsibility by finding a buyer; and even if we were fortunate enough to do so it would be at a 'fire-sale' price. The repairs will cost several ££m. Clearly we do not have the funds to do this ourselves, and no private philanthropist has volunteered to undertake this!
In absentia said philanthropist, they have applied for Heritage Lottery Funding. If we fail to get funding from them, and can still find no private philanthropist, the Institute will probably be bankrupt within 5 years, so it is vital that this funding is obtained. Initially they were turned down - as are almost all first-time applications - but were encouraged to reapply having reduced some specified risks.
The risks in question were:
a) the scheme was trying to do too much at once - it needed breaking down into phases, with each phase having a separate application for funding
b) the management needed tightening - in particular we needed to reduce the turn-over of directors, and we needed people on the Board who had experience of managing a works project of this scale and also someone who could get control of the finances.
 
The three who were due to stand down and present themselves for re-election were the Chairman (no-one else was prepared to take on this role), the only member with experience of handling a works project on this scale, and our head of finance! If any of these failed to be re-elected we would almost certainly fail in the HLF application. Since two of them have serially failed to be elected in the past it was a strong possibility that at least one of them would fail in a contest, with disastrous results for the application - and consequently for the BHI. 
Mr Giles explained this individually to all the people standing for election, and I now believe that those who withdrew their candidacy did so entirely voluntarily, without any undue pressure, and that, had they decided they still wanted to stand for election, no further pressure would have been applied. 
We have now ticked the boxes required by the HLF in the new application which is about to be submitted, and have good reason to hope for the fist stage - agreement in principle - to be granted. There then follows a year of putting the detail on the skeleton plan, and a lot of work agreeing on contractors and sorting out exact costings for various aspects. This is the other reason why it was so important to retain the existing Board - we need the continuity. It would be an almost impossible task, even for someone with experience in this field, to do that work starting from scratch without having been involved in the project already.
Provided the HLF are satisfied with the result of that year's work they will then release the funds for the work to start. There is a very strong probability of this as they will have someone on the team, making sure that we do satisfy their requirements! The building can then begin the journey towards being an asset rather than a mill-stone.

As I say, I went to the AGM not knowing most of this, and consequently being minded to raise objections to the three having been persuaded to withdraw. "Surely it is up to the membership to decide who is the right person to be on the board?" and similar sentiments, but having heard the full story I changed my mind and voted for the re-election. 
However, I did so on this occasion because of the exceptional situation we are in, and with the specific caveat that I believe it should not be allowed to become the norm, as it would risk resulting in a self-selecting clique holding on to power, which is not good for any organisation.

Thursday, 23 October 2014

Gliding???

As some of those of you who follow this may know, I took up gliding last year...
I am currently taking a week of holiday in Scotland on a gliding expedition with a group from the Aston Down club at  a gliding centre called Portmoak, where there is a lot of 'ridge' and 'wave' soaring - whereas at the club's home it is almost entirely thermal soaring.
This looked like being a great chance to gain some new skills. I was very hopeful of getting a fair bit of time actually in the air, as most of the group had brought their own gliders, so after checking that they were OK with the local site the instructor would be 'largely at my disposal for the rest of the week'. Well, that was the theory...
Most of us drove up on Saturday, and the club's 2-seater glider (a DG500) was 'rigged' that afternoon - i e taken out of the trailer and the wings and tail-plane fitted to the fuselage.
Day 1(Sunday) was a bit blustery, but most of the group got cleared.
Day 2 the rest of them got cleared and I got my first flight ~ 1½ hrs
Day 3 was VERY strong winds so it was only OK for either quite experienced pilots on their own or less experienced ones with instructors - so again I only got one flight of ~ 1½ hrs
Day 4 was a washout after the very first flights (of which I was not one)
Day 5 (today) is a total washout
Day 6 (Friday) looks hopeful...
Day 7 (Saturday) everything will be being packed up and we drive home.

You really do need to be quite an optimist in this game!  Thank you hurricane Gonzalo... :-(

The one consolation is that it has not cost much - ~ £230 so far for the week in self catering chalets, my part of the week's hire of one of the club's 2-seater gliders & launch fees (but excluding my fuel cost getting to & from here).

Next Friday/Saturday will be spent on a narrow boat so I hope the weather will be a bit better by then!

Speaking of fuel costs, please can I ask anyone who does any sort of high mileage to consider having an LPG system fitted to their vehicle? Not only is it about half the price of petrol, it is also far better for the environment...
Yes, it does cost a bit to get it fitted, and the tank takes up a bit of space (generally the spare wheel well), but I reckon with my car's MPG (5.5 m/l on petrol, ~ 4.1 on LPG) and the distance I travel each year (20,000 miles +) it will pay for itself in about 9 months, and there are plenty of places to fill up these days. With a full tank of both petrol and LPG I can go for 650 miles without filling up!


On the work front, I have just completed my first overhaul of a 'Congreve' clock - great fun, especially since the table had not been properly balanced and was not flat, it had the wrong mainspring, and there was no stop-work for the fusee - to name but a few of the faults...

Next up, an 'elephant' version of the swinging mystery clocks. This one starts to trip as the amplitude decays... The pivots are all good, and I have bushed the worn holes. I can't fit a weaker one to prevent it tripping at the reduced amplitude as they don't make one, so hopefully a stronger mainspring will prevent it decaying to this extent!

Thursday, 15 May 2014

relocating a wheel...

I have in the workshop a bracket clock with a badly worn escape wheel pinion. Surprisingly the 3rd wheel teeth do not show the normal step formed when there is this sort of wear in the pinion with which it meshes. It is mounted on a collet at the front, rather than on the pinion head. Although the collet has quite a wide head so there was potential to re-seat the wheel further back by reducing the thickness of the collet head,  I could not do so because it would have fouled on the fusee stop-nib, but and there was room to move it closer to the front plate without it fouling on anything. I decided to do this rather than turning it off the collet, and mounting it on a new one.
However, English & French clock wheel collets tend to be soft-soldered onto the arbor, and this one was no exception - so how do you move one without loosing concentricity? This is my answer...
I have an 8mm watchmakers lathe for which I have a (reasonably) 'true' 3-jaw chuck. The collet body to which it is attached is bored out down the centre. I made up a female centre on a bar of carbon steel which is a fairly tight push fit at the front end, with the rest of the bar reduced slightly so it slides down the collet and draw-bar without too much resistance, and long enough to stick out at the back end of the draw-bar.
To move the wheel I mounted it in the 3-jaw chuck with exposed end of the arbor supported in a female tail-stock and the made-up head-stock centre up against the pivot inside the body of the chuck.
With the lathe running very slowly, I warmed up the collet with a spirit lamp, maintaining a slight pressure on the bar down the centre of the headstock.  Once the arbor stopped rotating because the solder was soft and there was pressure on the ends of the arbor, I eased the tail-stock back slightly, re-clamped it and waited for the arbor to start turning again, all the while maintaining pressure on the head-stock centre.
The collet is now re-positioned with the wheel still concentric with the pivots, and meshing with an undamaged part of the escape pinion.
While the job (including making the head-stock centre) probably didn't take any less time than re-colleting the wheel would have, all parts are still original; and, of course, I now have the head-stock centre so in future this job will be a lot quicker!

Wednesday, 23 April 2014

On the move...

Quite a disrupted year so far ...
It started off with a broken collar bone towards the end of January, which put me out of action (in business terms) for about 3 weeks, then I had a solid week of major disruption in the workshop & the flat above it, while the storage heaters were ripped out and a 'wet' heating system was installed along with an air-source heat pump and hot-water tank, and now we are on the move domestically (though the business is staying put)! Not sure how much 'holiday' time I still have available... :-(

My wife (an Anglican priest) has a new appointment so we are moving to Coventry from Stroud - from a house with quite large rooms and a double garage to one with somewhat smaller rooms and no garage, loft or cellar - rather a problem as the garage was stuffed with all sorts of goodies we have to find space for!

The things you find when you move into a 'new' house... I moved a wardrobe from one room into another the other day and found that not only was the wall behind it completely bare plaster (the rest of the room has lining paper over the plaster but this bit was not even papered), it also had a lot of deep holes in the plaster and into the brick-work, some of which had bits of wood slotted in so clearly there was something heavy attached at some point. A lot of 'making good' to be done here.  :-(

It is amazing the number of people/organisations you have to notify when you move house. Everything from the DVLA - 2 separate envelopes, one for the car registration document and a different post-code for the driving license to any charities you make a regular payment to as they want to send you annual returns etc... all financial institutions where you have money (banks, share holdings, building societies), and of course all your friends! Thank goodness most of them can be notified by a single email to multiple addresses... It still took me all morning and part of the afternoon though - and some I have not been able to do as they need proof of the new address - utility bills or bank statements in your name at the new address. Just as well they don't all need this or you would not be able to supply it!

Going back to the heat pump (which is basically a large fridge in reverse), it comes with the added incentives (over & above the reduced cost of operation and reduced CO2 into the atmosphere) that A) I no longer need gas cylinders for the hot water geyser - and expensive way of supplying hot water - and B) there is a Government pay-out for renewable heat generation. Running the pump to produce hot water consumes less electricity than would be used to heat the water directly so for 1 unit used you get the equivalent of ~ 3.7 unit's-worth of heating. The extra 2.7 units qualify for the subsidy. They work out how much heat the house looses per day on the basis of the construction, insulation levels and wall/roof area (assuming a room temperature of 21°), and the amount of hot water you are expected to use; and calculate how many units you will therefore use in total, subtract the units used to run the pump to produce this amount of heat and pay you for the remainder... It should pay for itself within about 7 years I think, and the Barn is now really cosy.

Now I have to work out the most efficient way of using the pump - do I program it to heat the place up to more than the required temperature using night-rate power (at half the price) and use the fact that the walls are 2 foot thick as a heat-source for the rest of the day (so the pump hardly works on the day-rate power) or do I rely on generating enough power from the PV array to run it during the day, saving on the amount of power I buy in even at the night rate because I don't need the boosted temperature to start with??? - I think probably one during the winter and the other in summer! - I have a meter showing whether the PV array is generating more (or less) power than I am using and by how much much, so if it goes above a certain level I can turn up the heat for free - and I'm still getting paid for generating the electricity in the first place! (cue a smug grin...)

Having it fitted did also mean I had the most massive spring clean ever which I guess was not a bad thing!








Tuesday, 4 February 2014

Miscelania

Have you ever noticed how jobs often come in batches? - A collection of longcase clocks may be followed by a bunch of carriage clocks, then maybe some French drum movements, - but for some reason they often do come in clumps...
Well, I had just completed a collection of drum movements and was working on the next bunch - several fusee bracket clocks when I broke my collar-bone! I think they will have to go onto the back burner for a while when I get back to work, and be replaced by the next batch which happen to be barometers... no 'heavy' work involved in these. :-)

On the subject of injuries, this is one I can seriously recommend avoiding if at all possible. It is not so much the pain (in my case this does not seem to have been a big issue after the first few days) so much as the incapacitation involved. I have worked perfectly happily while on crutches with a leg in plaster, but not being allowed to use one of your hands is very limiting! The biggest problem is likely to be preventing myself from overdoing it before the shoulder is properly mended...

On a different note (I use the word advisedly!) I was recently contacted by someone who said I needed a 'Performing Rights' license if I was to play any music in the workshop despite being a sole trader. While I am all in favour of musicians being able to earn a living wage, the music I (very occasionally) play is all stuff I have bought or been given, so I do not believe I should have to pay a license to play it to myself! I was very wary when I realised what organisation they were from as I had heard that they were intransigent and took no notice of the individual situation. The individual I spoke to seemed to justify this reputation, and they sent me an invoice. However, I rang them on receipt of the invoice, and reiterated that I did not feel it was appropriate as I only ever play music to myself, turning it off when a customer was with me; and this time they did listen and agreed to cancel the invoice - so they are not all bad!

An interesting little job came in the other day - an 8-day 'strut clock'. Not so unusual you might think, but this one had no apparent means of setting the hands. On the back was a captive winding bow screwed onto the winding arbor - and nothing else. There was no rocker-bar button to press, no bezel-setting mechanism, no unused hole in the back cover - nothing....
Nothing that is, until you took the movement out of the case when you could see that the previous 'repairer' clearly did not know what (s)he was doing at all! The winding arbor was supposed to be able to be pulled outwards (like a watch winding stem) and then the wheel would engage the hand-set wheels, but that twit (whoever it was) had deliberately fitted a brass bush on the arbor under the top plate preventing it from being pulled into this position.. - there are even a pair of V-groves on the arbor with a detent acting in them to locate it in each position and even that was not enough to stop the imbecile!

Another, similarly idiotic, person had replaced the date-ring on a 3-train bracket clock I have currently in for attention - but had set it up so that the tip of the tooth on the inside of the ring was in the middle of the time winding hole - so that whenever you tried to wind the clock it nudged the date ring round so the date was no longer central in the hole - and often often far enough for the indexing nib to butt onto the top of the next tooth and stop the clock... so that replacement date ring has now had to be replaced again (after adjusting the nib so that it left the teeth either side of the winding hole!).
Why do these people do it???

Friday, 16 August 2013

Israel trip, final part - Days 9 & 10

Day 9 - Tuesday
We were guided today by Jonathan Cook - a journo who has lived here for 11 years & is married to a Maronite Palestinian. He gave us some very interesting info about the 'tidying up' of Nazareth before the Pope’s visit in 2000, which included shutting down the market for about 4 years while everything was repaved, drains put in etc. For those years the market was 'temporarily' relocated to Nazareth Illit (translates as elite in either the higher or the better sense - both intended here - & commonly called Upper Nazareth to outsiders) - where it still operates -with the result that this art of the town died and has never really recovered. This is also partly because Nazareth was not tourist zone A, not to be confused with the Oslo Accord zones. These are areas within Israel rather than the occupied territories which the Israeli government has decided to promote for tourism. Developers in a tourist zone A get 30% of the development costs back from the government, so naturally no-one did any development in Nazareth which wasn’t zone A. Consequently, there were no decent hotels, & no-one stayed here - they went to Tiberias, which was Zone A (and indeed still is). Nazareth got upgraded to Zone A for the Pope’s visit, so some hotels were built in time for it - and, co-incidentally for the start of the Second Intifada, which effectively killed all tourism for several years, so those hotels went bust... Public belief in the safety of the area is now beginning to recover and some tourism coming here - so hopefully the souq can re-invent itself as a tourist destination and may then recover. 
He also gave us a fairly thorough general historical briefing, the gist of which follows:
When the state of Israel was founded about 500 Palestinians villages were destroyed, some of then replaced with Israeli villages and some simply razed to the ground & forest planted in their place - fir/pine trees which are
A) unproductive food-wise
B) by their presence prevent other crops being planted/houses being re-built 
C) sour the ground, so even if they are felled nothing will grow for a while
D)  hide the fact that this has happened in the first place and
E) make it look more like home for immigrants from northern Europe!

The inhabitants of these settlements are now either 'absent absentees' (i e living abroad) or 'present absentees' (i e living in Israel, but not in their home towns) – come back Rumsfeld, all is forgiven!
Of the Palestinian settlements that survived - about 200 - only 124 were recognised; the other 76 still exist but are 'unrecognised' - not on any maps, have neither any roads to them, nor water, electricity or any other amenities (though apparently this is slowly improving). These are mostly in the Negev (Bedouin settlements) but also some in the part of Israel north of the current border with the West Bank. There are now plans to clear a large number of those in the Negev and 're-settle' the inhabitants in new towns away from their land.
Of the 124 recognised Palestinian settlements in Israel the only city is Nazareth  - the only Palestinian city in Israel - and therefore a prime target for Judaisation...The reason it was spared is the Basilica of the Annunciation -  Ben Gurion realised it would not be good publicity for the fledgling state to destroy this! He was already way outside the border agreed by the UN and he needed allies not enemies at the UN.... so despite loads of surrounding villages being destroyed the city was spared, and many refugees fled to it. Up to 1948 Christians had been in a majority in Nazareth, but the influx of refugees, although it contained a mix of Muslim & Christian, was mostly Muslim and has tipped the balance the other way. It's now 60% is Muslim, but Christians still run all the institutions. To counter the perceived threat this Muslim influx presented Nazareth Illit was founded, the civil institutions which had been run from Nazareth (which had been the capital of the Galilee) were moved to Nazareth Illit, and the industrial areas and military bases which are in (or at the edges of ) Nazareth were annexed into Nazareth Illit, so their rates went to Nazareth Illit not to Nazareth - keeping the municipality strapped for cash... Despite this, Nazareth is a highly privileged city - a good place for a Palestinian to live, whereas Nazareth Illit is a lousy place for a Jew to live - who wants to live cheek-by-jowl with a bunch of terrorists after all...??? - so houses in Nazareth Illit are very hard to sell, but loads of people are wanting to do so. The Mayer has bought-in advice which includes building a district for the ultra-orthodox Jews.... (which will of course be on annexed land).
 In Nazareth there was a fair bit of friction as a result of the clean-up operation... this was in part due to the Christian sites and their lands being retained by the Christian denomination which owned them before 1948, whereas the land and buildings owned by the Muslim mosques (and the land held by them for the community - about 10% of the total) was all appropriated by the state with the imams being re-instated as state employees, but under the control of the state which the Christian priests are not. Consequently when the plaza in front of the Basilica of the Annunciation was to be re-developed (having demolished a rather dilapidated Muslim school) there was a call for it to be a BIG mosque - not least because it was a site revered by followers of one of Salah a-Din’s nephews. This did not happen - it was developed as a 'holding area' for the tourists coming to the Basilica - though with a frame-work which is in the shape of a mosque so they immediately thought 'OK, we have our mosque' and put out their prayer mats. These they were forced to remove (but a compromise was worked out that they could use it as a mosque on Fridays, provided it is cleared the rest of the week). However the frictions from this meant that there was a demonstration by the Mohammedans and the Christians called for a counter-demonstration to 'defend their holy sites' and a riot ensued...
Later, shortly after the second intifada erupted in 2000, the Israeli police entered Nazareth and shot dead three people from Nazareth – 13 across the Galilee - and injured hundreds more while they were holding peaceful protests against the killing of pals in the Occupied Territories. The police lied, saying the protesters had shot their own in the back of the head but actually an inquiry later proved the police had used live ammo.

Israel has a peculiar legal situation... To start with there are two different citizenship laws depending on ethnicity. The Right of Return Law of 1950 gives all Jews worldwide the right to immigrate to Israel and instantly become full citizens. They are considered to be Jewish nationals who have not yet taken up citizenship. This right extends to anyone who has a single Jewish grandparent. This complicates things as the Rabbis only accept as Jewish someone whose mother is a Jew… and there are no secular institutions (only religious ones) for things like registering hatches, matches & dispatches; so for example you have to get married in church (or go abroad to get married in a secular venue, which is recognised on your return). Other ethnic/religious groups have a different level of citizenship under the Citizenship Law of 1952, (which, for example, precludes joining the IDF for Palestinians, which in turn prevents application for a lot of jobs open only to people who have served in the IDF). Before the Oslo accord it did not present too much of a problem as you could move relatively freely between Israel & the West Bank, but after it you had to decide which side you were going to live and stick with it. A Palestinian can't easily get citizenship of Israel - every time they think they are about to qualify the rules get changed to require even longer residence or whatever. Although there are (supposedly) "only" 57 laws which actively discriminate against Palestinians there is a lot of sub-legal discrimination (like the jobs example above), so those laws are the tip of the iceberg. There are 137 different ethnicities or nationalities recognised by the Interior Ministry for citizens of Israel, only one of which is a full national - i e Jews - and those 137 nationalities do not include Israeli - who is an Israeli? "Israeli" exists only as a citizenship (i e someone who lives in the country of Israel), not a nationality. Civic or individual citizenship rights are superseded by national rights and only Jews are entitled to national rights. This is the basis of the discrimination. Both Jew & Palestinian live in the country of Israel & the Jews want these to be separate nationality categories. The passport says Israeli, but that simply means from Israel (which is the name of the land rather than the race). For example Jonathan said he was an Israeli citizen but a British National. Only Jewish nationals have full citizenship rights. (ID cards distinguish between Jews & Gentiles by the calendar used for the DOB!) - and no-one can buy the freehold of a property in the 93% of Israel designated as ‘state land’ - only a 99-year lease on land 'held in trust for the Jewish Nation'.

After this history briefing we went for a picnic on the site of one destroyed village, Lubia, which has now been planted with forest, then drove to another, Hittin, which has just vanished apart from the old village well and, several kilometres from it, a mosque built by Saladin to commemorate the final decisive battle at which he defeated the Crusaders who were then forced to leave the Holy Land. Being (Jonathan believes) one of only 3 built by Saladin and still standing, this should be a UN world Heritage site, but is currently threatened by some road building which is rather close.... and finally to a third one, Saffuriya, which we just drove to & from without leaving the bus, but which has now got a moshav (similar to a kibbutz) built over it. These were all large and important villages before ‘48. After this we went to a private museum put together by one of the ex-residents of the last village, Saffuriya, who had fled to Lebanon as a 13-yr-old but returned a few months later (before the border was closed). When his sister died (probably of meningitis) and his mother started spending all her time at the grave-side, his father decided the only answer was to get her away from that place & return home - so they did. He gave a very dignified & moving talk about it all...
Back to the hotel for supper and a final briefing before painting the town red (I wish :-)  ) then to bed.

Reflection: Shortly after our return one of us spotted an article on the Guardian in which a Jew was trying to justify the settlements as ‘being on sound moral ground’, and as part of that justification claimed that ‘no Jewish settlements have been built on destroyed Palestinian villages’. (There were a lot of other claims which even if correct - which was debatable! - were not justifications, despite his attempt to use them as such.) However this particular claim stands out as manifestly false, having been to just such a settlement. It makes me wonder how much the Jews in Israel, and, indeed, the rest of the world, actually know what is really happening in Israel – have they looked for themselves or just accepted the line fed to them by the Israeli government? Someone in the group, when asked ‘how can they do this?’ replied ‘how can someone who was abused as a child become an abuser?’ Makes you think….


Day 10, Wednesday.
9.30am Having loaded all our bags onto the bus, we had a short ride down the High Street & were dropped off for a final thought at the Church of the Synagogue (very beautiful & peaceful) before having some shopping/sight-seeing time, then back on the bus at 12 for the ride to the airport.

In the final briefing before the bus to the airport, Nive mentioned the following points (among others):
This is the 65th anniversary of Al Nakba - retirement age! – Amos Trust trying to do 65 events to raise awareness. A secure peace for Israel can only come through a just peace for Palestine. Remember the 'living stones', and the different historical narratives.

If nobody speaks of remarkable things, how can they be called remarkable?



If you are affected by any of what I have written, I would be happy to discuss it with you, or you can find out more from the links below....
Either way, and whichever side you are on, please pray that the current round of peace talks bears lasting fruit! As I say above, a  secure peace for Israel can only come through a just peace for Palestine.


Links:
Amos Trust: http://www.amostrust.org/
Holy Land Trust: www.holylandtrust.org
Combatants for Peace: www.combatantsforpeace.org
Another member of the party's blog: http://10daysmay.wordpress.com/

Jonathan Cook: www.jonathan-cook.net

Thursday, 15 August 2013

Israel trip Part 6, Day 8 - Monday

Day 8 - Monday
We set out today for the shores of Lake Galilee, to walk in His footsteps in the countryside. We started by buying stuff for a picnic at a supermarket then past Migda (the modern spelling of Magdala where Mary came from) to the church on the (supposed!) spot where Jesus fed the 4000 - where there is the Church of the Multiplication Of the Loaves & Fishes (AKA Mensa Christi, or the Table of Christ) which has some wonderful Byzantine mosaics on the floor. The rock which He 'used' as a table was the altar of the original church, but was reduced in size and moved during the re-build by the Byzantines. It is now under the current altar. Rather commercialised, including a souvenir shop & carp pool.
From there it was a short walk to the Church of the Primacy of St. Peter (where he had the triple question 'Do you love me?') - somewhat less commercialised and we were able to paddle in the lake - which most of us did. Shoals of (very!) small fish, but no-one was able to catch one! Confusingly, of the two churches, this was the one with a tablet engraved Mensa Christi... but I guess he needed something on which to break the fish he had grilled. The wind started to pick up & the lake got noticeably choppier, so it is easy to imagine that it could get quite rough in a strong wind.
Next we went to the Greek Orthodox Church at Capernaum (as of the Wedding) for lunch on a table shaded by a trellis of vines, & with the lake at one end. Very nice. The church itself was amazing - barely any wall not covered with frescos all depicting scenes from His ministry (plus one of the death of Mary, and a wonderful 'doom' fresco).
Our final place today was the Mount of the Beatitudes, where we had a short reading of the Beatitudes from the 'Message' translation, followed by an extract from a book by Elias Chacour with his 'interpretation' of the word translated as 'Blessed'. He believes the original Aramaic word is an active word meaning 'get up and do something' in order to get the reward referred to in the second half - makes sense to me! After that we had a bit of time to wander and wonder, including looking at the church, which has a circular interior with an inner circular sanctuary. In the outer ring a choir from California was singing ‘a capella’ - and beautifully! A real bonus... This was definitely a place of peace, even with the tourists.
After that it was back on the bus for the trip back to Nazareth to our hotel. Supper @ 7 and then into the town!


Reflection: Today was the only whole day when we were not getting a ‘political’ input – purely a chance to walk in his footsteps – though I found our chances of doing so somewhat restricted by property boundaries – not surprising these days, but still a bit frustrating. Again, interesting how close together the various locations are – though still a fair step if on foot. A ‘reflective’ day – time to think over what we had seen & heard, and pray about it.

Wednesday, 14 August 2013

Israel trip part 5 - Days 6 & 7

Israel Trip - Day 6 - Saturday


A morning for shopping in Bethlehem, leaving the hotel at 10.00. I went with a group and the guy from Holy Land Trust and visited the 'Grotto of the Milk' - an offshoot of the cult of the Lactating Virgin in the middle ages - supposedly some of Mary's milk dribbled from Jesus' mouth onto a stone here!!! Various pious people and an anatomically poor painting of Mary with her right boob out feeding the infant, but nothing of interest. We then had a coffee and a sit-down, I did a little more shopping & then lunch, after which we set off for Nablus on the coach, passing the Lion's Gate into Jerusalem on the way.
On arrival some of us (after checking in at the Al Qasr hotel & dumping bags in our rooms) immediately got back onto the coach & went to the old town of Nablus - which was called Sychar in biblical times - through the souq where we had some 'kanafeh' - and watched them making it. Huge round trays of (goat?) cheese mixed with sugar and (vermicelli?) and topped with ground (maize?), then to visit the Turkish Baths built in 1225AD - we went in, but only as far as the first chamber as it was in use at the time and we had women with us. In the souq there is a street called The Street of Martyrs, commemorating Palestinians who fell in the Second Intifada – with posters of their pictures (and of Arafat) everywhere. Nablus was one of the ‘hottest’ areas during the 2nd Intifada, with the old town being a particularly hard nut for the Israeli forces to crack, so there were quite a few casualties. Then back to the hotel in the new part of the city for supper on the roof-terrace before bed. Glorious views from the roof terrace spoiled by settlements & security fences on all the surrounding hill-tops....
(no reflection today!)

Day 7 - Pentecost Sunday
We left Nablus and the Hill Country Of Jerusalem, into very fertile plains, and went to a town called Al Zababdeh (south of Jenin) which is a Christian stronghold with several Catholic (different denominations) and Anglican churches, where we would have had the Eucharist, but most of the congregation had got passes to go to Jerusalem for Pentecost so there was no service. We had one of our own - a few short prayers & a reading - in the Episcopal church which had inscriptions everywhere in Arabic, very familiar-looking hymn books - the tunes were the same and so were the hymns except that they were written in Arabic) and an OHP displaying things in English! If I remember correctly the inscription on the pulpit is ‘Yea though I walk through the valley of the Shadow of Death, Yet will I fear no evil’ in the top half and ‘Dedicated to the memory of…’ in the bottom. We were shown round their facilities (including 2 guest rooms), which are supported by the Diocese of Jerusalem, had lunch with them and then went to Jenin, which is the centre of the olive oil industry, but sadly with no time to stop & shop... We went straight to the Freedom Theatre in the heart of the refugee camp - though it did not look much different from the rest of the town!
The Freedom Theatre was founded by a lady who had been in one of the terrorist gangs that had pushed the Palestinians out in '48, but later married a Palestinian and came to realise what she had done so tried to do something to make up for it. Her son (an actor) then joined her; and when she died of cancer he took over. He was shot a few years ago. No-one has been arrested - the authorities think they know who did it but can't get the proof required. It is the only theatre in the area, and Jenin, like Nablus, was a hot-bed of resistance to Israeli rule so there were a lot of kids with PTSD (especially after the second intifada) so theatre & visual arts generally are really important.
As we were about to leave Jenin we dropped off our guide since he, being Palestinian, would not be able to cross over into Israel (Galilee area being completely Israeli), and headed off for Nazareth across the Plains of Megido. Huge open spaces with very fertile agricultural land. Ahead as we approached was the Mount of Transfiguration. Then up the steep slope into Nazareth town - no longer a village! -to the Golden Crown Hotel. When we got there we got all excited - it had a swimming pool - but sadly this was the new Golden Crown, not the Golden Crown (Old Town)...   :-(   The right hotel, when we got there, only has a reception foyer on the ground floor, no bar or other facilities to speak of and no staircases you can use (emergency use only). Just 2 lifts, and a very limited bar in the restaurant, not even a lounge area. NOT somewhere I would have chosen, but there you go.
I went for a wander with another couple into the old town (& the Palestinian quarter) and the (Catholic) Church of the Annunciation (called the Church of all Nations, then back for supper. Nothing was planned for the evening so I went out with my book & found a bar …

Reflection: It brought it home to me just how pervasive the control is, that, for a whole block of people in Zone B to get passes into Jerusalem, the reason needed to be so good a that it had to be for a festival like Pentecost – and these are Christians (clearly, since it was for a Christian festival!) not Muslims, so unlikely to be suicide bombers (no ‘instant transport to heaven & 100 virgins’ for a martyr) – in fact the Christian section of the Palestinian population mostly stayed out of the armed struggle. Similarly the fact that we could not take our Palestinian guide into Galilee – though that is less surprising since at least part of Palestine is a separate country – albeit heavily controlled by Israel – but it does show that they treat it as a separate country when it suits them! The evidence of English influence on the Christian churches was very clear – the tunes in the hymn books (and the lay-out, albeit reversed), the style of architecture of many of the smaller ones, and even the use of English in (for example) the OHP… more than I would have expected for the short time we were in charge there. The contrast between the mountain country of Jerusalem & the fertile plains was huge, and very sudden – almost like a knife-cut.

Saturday, 10 August 2013

Israel trip part 4 - Day 5, Friday

Israel Trip, Part 4 - Day 5, Friday
Today we started by visiting a house that had been demolished & re-built. On the way there we passed the (current) end of the wall and could see that on the Israeli side this bit it is skinned with decorative stone covering (it is right beside a new settlement!), while the Palestinian side is plain concrete. We also stopped at a house in the lee of the wall, beside which were 2 demolished houses - both somewhat further from the wall (and further down the hill). This house is built on the side of the hill and has 2 stories below street level, and the corner uprights to support a roof for an extra floor above, but the day they were to put the roof on they were ordered to stop, not because they would be higher than the wall, but because it would spoil the view from the houses inside the wall which do come up above it! Opposite this house the wall is ridiculously high – partly as a retaining wall admittedly, but it must be about 40’ high (about 7 times the height of a man), and immediately across the road from the house… not a pleasant outlook. Carrying on through the village we came to the demolished/rebuilt house. The first house got demolished - (no building permit) - and the family were in a refugee camp for 7 years before Amos & The Holy Land Trusts rebuilt it for them. As soon as it was rebuilt a demolition order was put on it and 5 other houses in the village with 72 hours’ notice for an appeal - on a Wednesday evening, i.e. after the courts had closed, and they only work a half day on Thursday with Friday & Saturday off... There is your 72 hours gone! Thursday is really busy so the Holy Land Trust got onto their lawyer in Jerusalem - Drop everything and come and sort this please!.... well, he did manage to and they raised the funds to pay him - but the cases are still in the courts several years later. We then saw a house which is just the wrong side of the road that’s being built for the settlers to get in & out of a settlement just beside the village (the one overlooking the wall). This owner also refused to sell his land despite being offered a blank cheque, so they had to put a tunnel under the road to connect him to the village (costing an extra £1million) and are going to surround his house with an electrified fence 4m away from it all round except for the side connecting to the tunnel, which will have a locked gate which only his immediate family will be allowed through except by prior arrangement with the military... The road going past his house did go to Bethlehem, but is now closed off with a barrier meaning the whole village is going to be surrounded by the wall with only one way in & out. Incidentally the settler road comes into the sight line of another settlement across a valley, so half way down the slope, when it would come clear of some trees, the wall turns into an electric fence in order not to spoil their view!
From there we went to another house that was demolished and is being rebuilt. One day during the first Intifada the wife of the owner was visiting her mother in hospital in Jerusalem, her husband was at work and the kids at school when the bulldozers arrived without warning and started to demolish it. The woman's sister saw it across the valley & phoned her. She came & tried to stop them but could not get to them through military and police blocks - net result one destroyed family life. They have been staying with the in-laws in the meantime. The new one is not yet habitable (no windows or plumbing fittings for example) but well on the way... still the piles of rubble from the old house to clear, etc. Looking across the valley from it, we could see the most stupendous palace – turns out the owner was a Palestinian with dual American citizenship who had gone to the States as a young man and built up a chain of 26(?) 'gas stations' from which he was making a very nice pile. Net result this house, and a LOT of support for the village & neighborhood. These two re-builds have been done with help from Amos Trust/Holy Land Trust, and are a protest against the illegal occupation and control of planning permits by the Israelis.
Our next port of call was lunch in Battir public park - the next village across with the fancy palace. The locals said it was a 40 minute walk so most of us decided to walk. It turned out to be 40 minutes once we had reached an old road at the bottom of the valley, but to get to that involved crossing a lot of scrub, then terraced olive groves with the ground plowed and steep 'slides' down from one terrace to another - which took just under an hour to complete! Before we hit the terraces we crossed a trench dug by the Israeli army for their protection during one of the intifadas. The Israeli’s are trying to destroy the terracing around Battir (which goes back to Roman times) for another new settlement, but the Palestinians challenged this and have managed to get the area declared a World Heritage Site…. Looking out from the terrace of the restaurant we could see the railway in the distance (which follows the ‘Green line’ and, somewhat closer, the new ‘settlers only’ road with a swathe of land either side which has been ‘grabbed’ from Palestinian ownership.
After a very late lunch we went to an open air mass in the olive groves of Cremazon monastery which is about to lose them all to the Israeli bulldozers for a road to a settlement, and from there to a talk by Combatants for Peace - two Israeli ex-soldiers and a Palestinian ex-militant. As the Palestinian said - everyone wants peace but they all want their own peace - and everyone’s ideas about what constitutes a just peace is different, but they are trying to do something about that. So far the only person who is not prepared to negotiate has been the settler... but unfortunately there are a many more like him, and they have a lot of power in the Knesset. From there we went to what looked like quite a popular eatery on the edge of Beit Sahur called The Eagles Nest for a very welcome beer or three and our evening meal - excellent food, and then back to the hotel.


Reflection: The house demolitions are a very nasty way of making life as hard as possible for the Palestinians, in the hope that they will just give up & go, but it seems to be back-firing in much the same way as the Blitz backfired on the Germans by making the British more determined to resist. Roads to the Settlements (which are for Jews only) are taking huge amounts of farm land from the Palestinians – not just the width of the road but a wide ribbon either side as well – far wider than is needed for the wall itself, because they are not allowed within ‘X’ feet of the wall.

Tuesday, 6 August 2013

Israel trip, part 3

Day 4 - Thursday
The day started with a trip to a settlement called Ephrata, to hear a settler (immigrant from the US) try to justify their position. For someone brought up with his beliefs and fed with the misinformation that is disseminated, coupled with a lack of desire to dig and find out the true facts his opinions are (just about!) understandable. However, that point of view does depend on believing the myths... which are aided and abetted by the undeniable acts of terrorism which are the direct result of living under the pressure-cooker conditions of the Palestinians. On a more positive note he did say that, if there were mass rallies by the Palestinians demanding peace negotiations he at least would be happy for the wall to come down. He seemed to genuinely believe that it was simply there for security!! He also could not see that, just because the West had 'used disproportionate force' in dropping nuclear bombs on Japan this did not justify Israel doing the same to the Palestinians. Also, his line that the Palestinians had only been there for a generation or three while Jews were the rightful inhabitants due to having been there 2000 years ago (albeit not at any point in between) rang a bit hollow - not least because he ignored the fact that most of the indigenous population had been there since time immemorial, and were almost certainly descended from the Jews who were not evicted by the Romans (only the ruling classes actually got evicted leaving the peasantry in situ, & the DNA of the Palestinians is largely Semitic, rather than Arabic).
From there we went to Hebron - a Palestinian (Zone A) city, but unique among them in having a section which is Israeli. The main road through has been cut off by the Security Wall. The prime shopping area has been closed down and sealed off by the Israelis, who welded up the shutters across the shops in the street of gold- and silver-smiths (in some cases with the goods inside!). This whole area is now a ghost town. Sections of the souq have a wire mesh roof to prevent the settlers’ kids throwing stones down on the heads of the Palestinians - though of course this does not stop liquids of various sorts! (This part is known as 'the cage'.) From there to the Tomb of the Patriarchs (Abraham Isaac & Jacob + one wife each) in the Mosque of Abraham - well – all are in the same building but currently 4 are in a part which is a mosque & 2 (Isaac+ wife) in the other part which is a synagogue with 'only' a bullet-proof partition (partly glass) between them, though at different stages it the entire building has been a temple, church, mosque, church, mosque, church and mosque again! The current building was originally a crusader church....
We then had lunch (after a bit of shopping in his emporium) on the roof of the shop-owner opposite the mosque. He is in Israeli territory but is a Palestinian - but unlike most of them he can prove ownership irrefutably so they can't kick him out - but he can only walk across the road & into the Palestinian area; he can't walk to the left or right of his shop... while we were there the water ran out despite the water tanks on his roof because the water is not on 24/7 for Palestinians - the Israeli's control it and turn it off at will. They have 7 tanks on the roof, each about 1m diameter by ~ 1.3m high as well as a series of smaller plastic barrels, but all of these had run dry... (Each of those tanks holds just over 1 cubic meter of water which is 10,000 Litres). I clearly don't know if they had been fully filled last time the supply had been turned on, but they were certainly all empty then!
Most of the water in Israel/Palestine comes from aquifers under the West Bank. Under the Oslo Accord, Israel was given the right to 85% with the Palestinians only getting the remaining 15%, and all water extraction & distribution is controlled by Israel to ensure they get their share. They randomly cut off the supply to Palestinian’s, especially in summer months. (In the winter they cut off the electricity instead!) Consequently you can always tell a Palestinian-occupied building from an Israeli one, due to the water tanks on the roofs of the Palestinian ones.
After lunch we went to the Tent of Nations via a glass & ceramics factory where the glass-blowers were wearing sandals! The plates etc were hand painted –really rapid work – quite amazing to watch. We also passed the only camel butcher in Hebron! The Tent of Nations is another Palestinian establishment working for a peaceful settlement of the conflict. In this case it is a round hill entirely owned by a family who, like our lunch hosts, have impeccable title deeds (including from the Israelis in the early years of statehood!) who are nevertheless embroiled in 'land rights' court cases, and have had the road past them to Hebron blocked with giant boulders by the Israeli army. They have no water supply or electricity supply, so solar power is a Godsend technology! With it they can heat water, and pump it from underground cisterns. Even so they need to bring it in by bowser from the nearest village in the other direction from Hebron - quite a lot further.  They are entirely surrounded by settlements (including a 'spur' from one settlement which even by Israeli standards is illegal), all of which have mains electricity and water 24/7, but they still get demolition orders on the tents they put up to accommodate foreign visitors despite the illegal spur not getting any demolition orders on the houses; and when they say this they are told it is none of their business whether those other places have demolition orders on them or not! They have managed through legal means to stop the development of roads which would have cut through their land on both sides - or at least get it suspended - the case is still sub-judice (and is likely to remain so for some considerable time!). Again it is a case if Israel trying to make it so unpleasant that the occupants leave 'of their own choice' - at which point they seize the land as being 'unoccupied'! I left not sure whether or not to be inspired by their stubborn refusal to be ousted… They have even refused an open cheque - how many million do you want - and where do you want a residency visa for? Their response? ‘No. This land is our mother and WE do not sell our mothers...’ This turns out to be a typical reaction of the Palestinians who have had similar offers.
From there we went to Mar Saba monastery, Passing 'Herod’s Mount' on the way - a hill built by Herod to commemorate a famous victory, on top of which he had a palace, and bathing pools at the bottom. Mar Saba is probably the monastery with the longest occupation in the (western) world. It was almost certainly emptied briefly by the Persians, but apart from that appears to have been in constant use since the time of its founders in the first few centuries AD - I forget which one! There are buildings still in use as well as (now-deserted) cave cells - at its height about 5000 monks were here; meeting only on Sundays, and remaining in their cells the rest of the time – the Desert Fathers


Reflection: It is hard to understand how a people who have been persecuted as thoroughly and for as long as the Jews can then turn round and do the sort of things they are doing to the Palestinians, but they are determined ‘never to be in a minority again’ in their own country and since the Palestinians have a higher birth-rate they have to find ways of redressing this… Also, it is a very narrow country – you can fire an artillery shell from one side of it to the other, so they feel insecure militarily as well which aggravates the problem, especially as they think the only way to ensure peace it to defeat any possible enemies by force! 

Monday, 5 August 2013

Israel trip part 2

Day 3 - Wednesday
Woke at 6.00, went back to sleep and only woke up about 20 minutes before the bus left! More very heavy rain just before we left. No time for breakfast, but our first port of call was the offices of the Holy Land Trust where we were given a shot of coffee (which dealt with breakfast!), and a very interesting talk by Elias D'eis about conditions now and since 1948..
Among other things he said that under Israeli rule the educational curriculum (including history…) was dictated by Israel. The first Intifada lead to the Oslo negotiations and ‘Peace Accord’ with areas A,B,& C and a 5-year window to negotiate a final agreement. Sadly during those 5 years things got steadily worse, with the result that in 2000 the 2nd Intifada started and this was far more militant with areas A, B, & C suspended and full (Israeli) military rule enforced. The Holy Land Trust had been founded in 1992 aiming for peace & reconciliation – Conflict resolution, non-violence training & training of leaders for statehood (accepting that there were no credible leaders at that point!). – honouring the past, but looking to the future without war and working for international media connections (Israel controls most people’s access to info about Palestine) – and to create bridges using travel to the ‘living stones’ (i e people) rather than just the dead stones of churches etc – but going to both sides… The H L T also do house rebuilds (some with Amos Trust). He believes that interfaith relationships are good at the moment, but they are worried about them in the future. He also said that Bethlehem’s ‘Star Street’ was the main road for visitors going to the Church of the Nativity, with 96 shops on it – of which 80 have been closed since the 2nd intifada. Now most visitors go straight from the bus stop to the church & back without any time looking at the city… - probably due to it not being designated a ‘zone a’ tourism town (see day 9 for tourism designations & their significance).
To get an ‘unbiased’ report of the situation (or at least to get the Palestinian idea of one!) try www.pnn.ps – the Palestinian News Network.
From there we went to Manger Square and the Church of the Nativity - another one with a series of churches in the same place - the current door is so small (deliberately) you have to stoop to get in. Inside you descend to the 'cave where he was born' (oh yea...) - there are parts of the floor of the main naive which are excavated to the original mosaic of St Helens church, which was considered to have been made too holy to walk on after having the 'original cross' laid on it so it was covered over by a later emperor... Caves under the RC part (again many different parts for different sects - the main part being Orthodox) are where St Jerome lived while translating the Bible into the Vulgate. He was also originally buried there before being disinterred and transported to Rome.
During the first Intifada a group of protesters were besieged inside it and you can see the pock-marks from the bullets in some parts of the walls.
We then went for a walk along part of the 'Security Wall' - which cuts deeply into the city here in a very strange wiggle or 3, doubling back on itself several times, destroying part of the main road from Bethlehem to Jerusalem (Star St.) in the process, resulting in prime real-estate shops becoming totally worthless overnight. One building was surrounded on 3 sides by the wall, and since the upper stories are higher than the wall it has to have sheet steel shutters permanently over the upper windows. Another tall 5 (6? story) building on a rise near the wall was commandeered by the military Israeli for a while before being returned - but only the first 2 floors are allowed to be used as you can see over the wall from further up... All this apparently to ensure that Ruth's Tomb was kept inside Israel!
After that it was back on the bus for a short ride to the Shepherds' Field - which our guide for today (Rafat) said his great grandfather had sold to the Benedictines (who seem to be ubiquitous as 'guardians of the Holy Land'). (He also sold a different field to the Armenians and another to the Orthodox, each believes theirs is the real one!) Again, caves which are rife hereabouts, and which were used by the (wandering) shepherds up to the last century - demonstrating the meaning of the Lord being the 'gate' to the sheepfold as the good shepherd would lie across the opening.  Interesting snippet - sheep being carried is because of the shepherd breaking its leg to train it not to wander. He then carries it everywhere and feeds it until it can walk again, by which time it associates the shepherd with food and won’t wander off. Also  sheep don't drink from running water, hence 'He leads me beside still waters'... looking across the valley from the Shepherds' Field we could see a fairly recent Palestinian development and behind it an even newer Israeli settlement, which had permission to grow considerably, & towards the Palestinian  development, which would then become a 'threat' to those new units.... we could also see how much land the wall had taken from the Palestinians - not just on the far side but also a wide swathe on this side which they are no allowed to use.
After lunch we went to the Aida refugee Camp (in Bethlehem) - I don't recall the density of the population but it is VERY high - they can come & go freely inside Bethlehem (on the Palestinian side of the Wall that is!) and work (if they can find any...) but are supported hugely by the UN – food, medicine & education (though I think they have to go to a different camp for the major medical treatment). There is no privacy in the Camp - very cheek by jowl - and the sewerage system is not fantastic; the windows of the UN school are blocked in except for (relatively) narrow slits at the top to prevent any bullets from the watch-tower across the road being a danger to the staff or pupils (you can still put your fingers into the bullet-holes in the school gate) - despite this we were assured it is luxury compared to all other Camps. It is all 'proper' buildings now, and from the top of one house we got a really good view of the 'wandering wall'... Among other things it took out another HUGE area of farm-land just outside the refugee camp - the original plan was for it to go down the middle of this strip, but the church that owned the land (Armenian Patriarchate?) kicked up a fuss and asked why it could not go down the far side - which would be plenty for the protection of the settlement the far side. This was supposedly agreed, but then when it was actually built the wall came down the near side instead, and the Israelis blamed the church for not letting them go down the middle! There are a fair few houses on this strip of farms, which are totally cut-off. The owners have to walk quite a distance to a road, & then go to Jerusalem (having got a permit) before they can then come into Bethlehem...
We then had some free time in the Bethlehem souq, then back to the hotel to freshen up before heading out to a talk & barbecue at Wi'am - a 'Palestinian Conflict Resolution Centre - one of the things the director there (by name Zoughbi Zoughbi – and he said we could use either name!) said was that they tried to exchange 'the dialogue of arms (weapons) for the arms (body-parts) of dialogue' - very much trying to find a positive thing that can be taken from even the worst situation and to build on it - restorative justice being one of the key lines, along with education, support, advocacy, etc. He also said that Al Nakba is not a thing of the past, but a continuing issue - i e it is not just the creation of the State of Israel (which they could live with it there was a full and just settlement) but also the Occupation, the restrictions on water – more about this later - and freedom of movement, the house demolitions, the Wall etc. Then back to the hotel by ~ 8.15. A bunch of us went for a pint in Manger Square, but at 25 Shekels (£5)/pint I did no linger for a second!
Not much evidence of anything kicking off due to Al Nakba, day just the odd loud bang in the distance, though I think the itinerary was changed to avoid something - I think we should have gone to the Tent of Nations today rather than (as now) tomorrow.


Reflection: Interesting that the general attitude of Palestinians (and this is borne out by all the others we meet later) seems very much to be one of wanting peace, & being willing to live with a 2-state solution, provided it is one they see as just. They believe it is the Israelis who do not want peace, and scupper all negotiations with acts of provocation which cause a reaction from the Palestinian side after which the Israelis can say they refuse to negotiate with the Palestinians while they are under attack from them! The belief is that Israel will not accept any peace until they have the whole of Biblical Palestine (at least west of the Jordan) under their rule.

Friday, 2 August 2013

Israel trip, Part 1

Back in May I spent 10 days in Palestine/Israel with the Amos Trust, during which my eyes were opened to what is going on over there. I thought I had a reasonable grasp before I went, but I discovered that I didn't know the half of it.... I have delayed publishing this as I wanted to be certain that I would not get anyone into trouble...

This is 'Part 1'  as the title says. If you are interested  there will be several further parts over the next few days....

Day 1 - Monday
It started well. A pleasant flight - I had a window seat - and a very smooth landing at Ben Gurion airport. While waiting to get off the plane it started raining, which was a bit of a surprise as the forecast was for 0% possibility of precipitation for at least the first 5 days. Quite a heavy, but short-lived, shower.
After an unscheduled delay of about 1 1/2 hrs at the airport while our group leader, Nive, was interrogated, we made our way to the bus which was to take us into Jerusalem for the first night and set off leaving one of the group behind... - Nive paid for her taxi. 
More rain during the drive to the hotel. 
In a couple of places we passed rows of 'shells' of vehicles painted grey (not rusting, or distorted, but only shells) some at the side of the road and some in the central reservation. Down some very narrow roads (for a coach) to our hotel – our first introduction to the quality of the driver Sami.
After supper went for a walk into the Old City - Herod's Gate, Via Dolorosa and the West Wall - still packed at 10.

Reflection – security – they were paranoid because the group includes a lot of clergy (all in their dog-collars...), but Nive isn’t a minister; he has been back & forth several times, we will be having several tourist guides for the trip, not just one; & we will be staying in hotels outside the main tourist towns… - but 1 ½ hrs seems excessive. At least he WAS released – someone he knows was refused entry recently... This would have been bad publicity though.  :-)


Day 2 - Tuesday
Left the hotel at 8.30 with some very threatening clouds around, and went to the offices of Sabeel - a Palestinian Christian Ecumenical Peace Community trying to work out where they are theologically in the Bible - where do Christians fit in as Palestinians in the state of Israel? A very informative and moving talk from a lady of 77 called Cedar who was 12 and living in Haifa when the 'Catastrophe', or Al Nakba, (the setting up of the state of Israel) happened*... She had been brought up with the teaching that the bible is inerrant, that the good are rewarded and the bad punished, that the Holy Land was given to the Jews by God etc. They were quite happy for Jews to come (though some Palestinians were against the influx saying they would take over - which indeed they did!), but expected to still play a significant part in the new state. They also expected to return to their properties within a few months at most. Very few have done, & even fewer more will do so in the foreseeable future...
(*this should perhaps read ‘began’ rather than ‘happened’ – see near the end of day 3 in 'part 2')
From there we went to the Mount of Olives, to the 'Christus Pleuvit' church, on the spot where he is supposed to have wept over Jerusalem, and from which we had a good view of most of Jerusalem and a patchy view of the Garden of Gethsemane, and some wonderful gilded onion-domes on the Russian Orthodox church. 
I should say 'supposed' before all references to biblical locations (except the temple itself), as no-one can be totally sure about any of them in reality, but for the sake of simplicity assume it from now on. 
Our Palestinian tour guide, Rami, pointed out Christ's route from the Garden to the House of Caiaphas, the Antonine Tower (Pilate's Praetorium), the Citadel (where Herod was), back to the Antonine tower, and then to Golgotha where the Church of the Holy Sepulchre now stands. He also pointed out the Dome of the Rock and Al Aqsa mosques (side by side). Then down to the Garden of Gethsemane - with some wonderfully ornate work on the portico.  Back onto the bus for a drive into the Old Town past some (very) wide steps leading up to the walls of the temple - no gate there now, but there was in Jesus' time and this is the way he would have entered Jerusalem on the journey from Galilee since you had to have a certificate to say you were ritually clean to enter the Temple and the baths for that were in the valley below. Hence they are known as the Jesus steps. Into the Western Wall precinct (which Rami insisted on calling the Wailing Wall, probably as an act of resistance to Jewish rule), stopping to view the excavations of the south part of the temple and then the Western Wall itself (a second time in my case). As he pointed out, this was only ever a retaining wall to make sure the weight of the temple would not cause a land-slip - it was never part of the temple itself. Herod's temple was twice the size of Solomon's so it came very close to the edge of the mound. The stones of the lower half of the wall each have a recessed border, and these are the ones from Herod's time; the rest getting steadily smaller as the wall gets higher.
From there we retraced my walk of last night to the start of the Via Dolorosa, to the courtyard of Pilate’s Praetorium. Here he was condemned and flogged - 39 lashes (being 40, minus 1 for leniency!) - apparently 13 on one side, 13 on the other, and 13 on the back. Rami also said that the Romans are thought to have used fish-hooks on the ends of the lashes so after 13 strokes on the back there would be little or no skin left... From there we followed the Via Dolorosa for a few stations, had a break for lunch then continued along it through Arab souqs (very frustrating, not being allowed any time so stop & wander....) and into the Jewish Quarter (a VERY noticeable change in building and atmosphere - almost like a knife-cut) till we eventually got to the Church of the Holy Sepulcher, a Crusader church built over Golgotha and the site of the tomb. Queues of over an hour to descend to the 'tomb' itself, and so much bling around it was unbelievable. There is a bit upstairs where he is supposed to have been crucified, a bit at the back where he is supposed to have been washed and a bit downstairs in a crypt where St Helen was supposed to have found the 'True Cross', as well as a separate wing with Armenian altars and an entire village on the roof! Six different 'Christian' denominations fought for control of this building so in the middle ages a 'status quo' was agreed as to who had what rights/responsibilities and in some instances for what times of day they had them, and a Muslim family was given the keys. This agreement is still in force with the same family holding the keys, &every so often there is a flare-up when someone does something which is the right/responsibility of one of the other sects and sometimes it comes to fisticuffs. All very silly!
Then we went to Caiaphas' house to see where Jesus spent his last night - though since tombs have been discovered underneath it and Jews were not allowed to build over tombs as they would be ceremonially unclean it seems unlikely to be the true site of the house of a High Priest... Our final point of call was a church on the 'site of Peter's triple denial', a few yards from the house.
We then go on the bus again for the drive to Bethlehem, passing through a check-point (freely - they only check people going INTO Jerusalem at this one, not people leaving) into the Occupied Territory (Area C – see on for an explanation of the zones) then passed HUGE red signs saying that 'this road goes into Palestinian Territory and it is illegal for any Israeli to pass into Area A as they will be risking their lives' (paraphrasing). This is an Israeli law not a Palestinian one. And so to Beit Sahur on the edge of the City of Bethlehem to our hotel for the next 5 days - The Ararat, completed about 6 months ago on the side of a very steep hill - arriving at about 5.30 having been on our feet almost all day... We are now in the heart of Palestine.

Reflection: It is far more compact than I realised, but incredibly hilly, the crosses were not high, but left the face of the victim just about at eye level so they could be spat at and reviled by passers-by, the Palestine-Jew situation now is closely analogous to the Jew/Roman situation of Jesus' time - to name but a few...

Zones of control in the Occupied Territories (or as the Jews call them, the ‘Disputed Territories), introduced following the Oslo Accord:
Zone A: complete Palestinian control – though intermittently violated by the Israeli military
Zone B: Palestinian civil control (supposedly including planning consent) but Israeli security control
Zone C complete Israeli control

In zones B & C the Israeli military can effectively veto all planning applications by claiming that there is a ‘security reason’ (which does not have to be disclosed) to block any proposed building. Very very few Palestinian planning applications that have been put before the Israeli authorities have yet been granted – thousands are still awaiting a hearing after many years pending. This means that they have to build without consent and then have a ‘demolition order’ put on their house/house extension. This may or may not be executed for many of years (with only about 72 hrs notice of when it is to be enforced by the military) but for every year that it is not enforced there is a hefty fine for having failed to demolish it, and when the Israeli’s do the demolition there is a further hefty bill for their services! Of course if the Palestinian decides to do the demolition themselves, they do not have to pay the fines/bills…